The Shocking Story of Sidnee Stephens’ Murder

14 mins read
The Shocking Story of Sidnee Stephens' Murder

Two fishermen made a grim discovery when they found a lifeless body near the Beaucoup Creek Bridge in Pinckneyville. The victim was later identified as Sidnee Stephens, a young girl who had recently gone missing from her home. 

The subsequent investigation into her death revealed shocking revelations that deeply affected the Perry County community. Among those implicated in the tragedy were individuals close to Sidnee, including her half-sister. Here’s the full account of what transpired in the unfortunate case of this 15-year-old girl.

Who is Sidnee Stephens?

Sidnee Stephens, the central figure in the tragic tale of the Town Saints murder, entered this world on May 15th, 1995, in the serene town of Murphysboro, nestled in Jackson County, Illinois, United States. Born to parents Jason Tritschler and Tracy Stephens, Sidnee grew up in a bustling household alongside four siblings, where love and laughter filled the air.

Her journey through life led her to Pinckneyville Community High School, where she pursued her education with diligence and dedication. Beyond academics, Sidnee was a cherished member of the tight-knit community at Oak Grove Baptist Church in Pinckneyville, where she found solace and camaraderie among fellow worshippers.

Sidnee’s story, though tragically cut short, serves as a poignant reminder of the fragility of life and the enduring impact of those who leave an indelible mark on our hearts.

Early Life Of Sidnee Stephens

Sidnee Stephens, a vibrant sophomore at Pinckneyville Community High School, was a beloved member of Oak Grove Baptist Church in Pinckneyville. Her zest for life knew no bounds, as she found joy in a myriad of activities. From crafting candy bracelets to grooving to music, attending concerts to mastering pool games, and indulging in outdoor adventures like fishing, swimming, and camping, Sidnee embraced every moment with enthusiasm and a contagious smile.

Her untimely departure has left a void in the hearts of her family and friends, who cherished her warm spirit and infectious laughter. Sidnee’s memory will forever be treasured by her devoted mother, Tracy Stephens (Randy Richmond), and her father, Jason Tritschler, along with her stepmother, Connie Tritschler, and a loving array of siblings: Zach “Bubby” Jeremiah, Dakota Wall, Tristin Tritschler, and Taylor Tritschler. She leaves behind a legacy of love and joy that touched the lives of all who knew her.

Sidnee’s circle of love extended to her grandparents, Jerry and Mary Ruth Tritschler, Larry Stephens, and Vicki Dale, as well as her great-grandmothers, Mauna Loa Bailey and Loa Runion, and her great-great-grandmother, Mary Waltemate. Her faithful German Shepherd, Declyn, stood by her side, offering comfort and companionship through life’s highs and lows.

In addition to her immediate family, Sidnee’s memory will be forever cherished by special friends like Stacy Hackworth and Tim Wall, as well as a host of beloved aunts, uncles, cousins, and friends who were touched by her warmth and kindness. Though she may no longer walk among us, Sidnee’s spirit lives on in the hearts of those who were fortunate enough to have known her.

Sidnee Stephens’ profile summary

Full nameSidnee Edith Cheyenne Stephens
Date of birthMay 15th, 1995
Zodiac signTaurus
Place of birthMurphysboro, Jackson County, Illinois, United States
ParentsJason Tritschler and Tracy Stephens.
Date of deathJuly 25th, 2010
Place of deathPerry County, Illinois, United States
Place of burialSunset Memorial Park Cemetery

What happened to Sidnee Stephens?

Due to her history of mental health challenges and previous suicide attempts, Sidnee often ran away from home and returned on her own. Therefore, when she disappeared on July 19th, 2010, her parents initially assumed she had left voluntarily, although they were concerned she might harm herself.

The news of Sidnee’s disappearance sparked widespread concern in the community, prompting a collective effort to locate her. As the search intensified, two fishermen made a grim discovery near the Beaucoup Creek Bridge south of Pinckneyville: human remains in the water. They promptly notified the authorities, who worked to identify the body. Sidnee’s lip ring and necklace helped confirm her identity, and a subsequent post-mortem examination revealed that she had died as a result of homicidal violence.

Sidnee Stephen and Dakota Wall

Sidnee and her half-sister, St. Dakota, shared a typical sisterly bond, spending time together as they grew up. However, as they entered their teenage years, their relationship strained, despite remaining part of the same social circle. Dakota eventually started dating Chad Bennett, a prominent figure in the local gang known as the P-Town Saints. Chad’s friend, Carl Dane, had previously dated Sidnee before they broke up.

Sidnee documented her experiences, including her past relationship with Carl, in a journal. However, when Dakota stumbled upon the journal, she was deeply hurt by its contents. According to Sidnee’s writings, she had allegedly been involved in a sexual affair with Chad Bennett.

The discovery of Sidnee’s journal caused significant turmoil between the sisters, exacerbating the existing tension in their relationship. Dakota’s feelings of betrayal and hurt were heightened by the revelation, further widening the gap between them. The situation also complicated their interactions within their social circle, especially considering Chad and Carl’s involvement.

Resolving the fallout from this revelation would require open communication and understanding between Sidnee and Dakota. Clarifying the circumstances surrounding the journal entries and addressing the underlying issues would be crucial in repairing their fractured relationship. However, navigating this delicate situation would prove challenging, given the emotional turmoil and trust issues involved.

Investigation into Sidnee Stephens’ death

The investigation into Sidnee’s murder commenced with interviews with her close friends and family members. On July 28th, her former boyfriend, Carl Dane, was brought in for questioning. Initially, he denied any involvement in Sidnee’s death. However, blood was discovered on his clothing, leading to his eventual confession. 

Dane admitted to strangling Sidnee until she lost consciousness, then transported her to a bridge, where he shot her.

The police, suspecting Dane’s accomplices, brought in James Glazier, another member of the P-Town Saints.

Glazier confessed to his involvement and implicated a third individual, Robbie Mueller.

On July 19th, Glazier and Dane unlawfully entered Sidnee’s home, with Mueller acting as a lookout, as disclosed later.

They subdued Sidnee and took her to a bridge, where Dane shot her before disposing of her body in the river.

Dane pleaded guilty to first-degree murder and received a sixty-year sentence. However, he was found dead in his jail cell the night before he was to be transferred to IDOC custody.

Glazier and Mueller were also found guilty in a bench trial. Glazier received a sixty-year sentence, while Mueller received thirty-seven years. Another individual, Chad Bennett, pleaded guilty to his involvement and was sentenced to twenty years in prison. Previous charges against Bennett were dropped in 2013.

Was Dakota Wall convicted for Sidnee Stephens’ murder?

Dakota Wall was convicted for her role in the murder of Sidnee Stephens, and charged with aiding the individuals who committed the crime. Allegations stated that she intentionally left the door to their home unlocked, facilitating the kidnapping of her younger sister by her acquaintances.

Wall argued she left the door ajar as a prank, unaware it would lead to Sidnee’s tragic demise.

However, law enforcement dismissed her explanation, leading to charges of first-degree murder, kidnapping, home invasion, and burglary.

Was Dakota Wall found guilty of Sidnee Stephens’ murder?

Dakota Wall was among those convicted for the tragic death of Sidnee Stephens. She faced accusations of aiding the individuals responsible for her sister’s murder. It was alleged that she intentionally left the door to their home unlocked, allowing her friends to abduct her younger sister. Wall defended herself by explaining that she had merely left the door open as a prank, never anticipating such a grave outcome. However, law enforcement didn’t accept her explanation, leading to charges of first-degree murder, kidnapping, home invasion, and burglary.

As for Dakota Wall’s current whereabouts, she is presently incarcerated. In 2018, she pleaded guilty to the charges and received a 26-year prison sentence. There is a possibility for her to be considered for parole after serving 10 years of her sentence. She is currently serving her time at the Lincoln Correctional Center, a women’s prison located in Lincoln, Illinois. Dakota Wall’s mother reportedly accepted the court’s ruling regarding her daughter’s conviction.

Where is Dakota Wall today?

In 2018, Dakota Wall pleaded guilty to her charges and received a 26-year prison sentence. There’s a possibility for her to be considered for parole after serving 10 years of her sentence. Currently, she is serving her time at the Lincoln Correctional Center, a women’s prison located in Lincoln, Illinois. Dakota Wall’s mother accepted the court’s decision regarding her daughter’s sentencing.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about the Murder of Sidnee Stephens:

Q: Who was Sidnee Stephens?

Sidnee Stephens, a 15-year-old from Perry County, Illinois, sadly died in a homicide, deeply impacting her community.

She grappled with mental health challenges and had a history of running away from her home.

Q: What happened to Sidnee Stephens?

A: Sidnee disappeared on July 19th, 2010, and her body was later discovered near the Beaucoup Creek Bridge. Investigations unveiled that she had been the victim of a premeditated homicide, perpetrated by individuals with whom she had connections, including her half-sister, Dakota Wall, and members of the P-Town Saints gang.

Q: Who were the perpetrators of Sidnee Stephens’ murder?

A: Carl Dane, James Glazier, Robbie Mueller, and Chad Bennett, linked to the P-Town Saints gang, were the main culprits. Carl Dane confessed to strangling Sidnee, followed by her being shot by Dane and Glazier. Bennett also admitted to his involvement in the crime.

Q: Was Dakota Wall involved in the murder?

A: Yes, Dakota Wall, Sidnee’s half-sister, was found guilty of aiding the perpetrators. She facilitated the kidnapping of Sidnee by leaving the door to their home open.

Although she denied expecting her sister’s death, she was found guilty of first-degree murder, kidnapping, home invasion, and burglary charges.


The Perry County community was deeply shaken by the murder of Sidnee Stephens.

What seemed a missing person case evolved into a tragic tale of betrayal and brutality, implicating Sidnee’s close ones.

The ensuing investigation unraveled a complex network of relationships and resentments that culminated in a devastating loss.

As justice was meted out, with convictions and sentences handed down to the perpetrators, including Sidnee’s half-sister, Dakota Wall, the community grappled with the aftermath of this senseless and heartbreaking crime. Sidnee’s memory serves as a poignant reminder of the critical importance of remaining vigilant in safeguarding vulnerable individuals and the profound consequences of overlooking warning signs within one’s social circle.

Stay in touch for more updates and alerts. Tribune Breaking!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Previous Story

Nikolai Peter Ingraham Wikipedia, Nationality, Career & More

Next Story

Peyton Parrish Wikipedia, Height, Career, Net Worth, & More

Latest from Blog

withemes on instagram